Austin Lumbard Lost the Election. So Why Is He Trying To Pack Tustin’s Committees on His Way Out?

Austin lumbard

This post was originally published on this site.

The outgoing mayor wants to lock in appointments to influential regional boards, distribute coveted paid assignments, and establish a new Veterans Advisory Committee just days before Letitia Clark takes office. The move could leave Tustin’s incoming mayor without a voice in selecting the city’s regional representatives—or an opportunity to serve on those boards herself.

When I coached basketball and baseball in Irvine, I tried to teach my players how to be gracious winners; hold your head up, congratulate your opponents on a god game and no showboating.  And when the lost, how to be good sports.  Shake hands, show sportsmanship, thank the officials, and support each other.  But sometimes there are bad winners who showboat, and bad losers who seek blame and not accountability.

What we have in Tustin is a sore loser.

Mayor Austin Lumbard lost his bid for reelection. Letitia Clark won.  And voters made their choice clear.  Elections have consequences, but MAGA Republicans are  try to avoid them in Tustin andin the state house in Austin, TX as the legislature is trying to limit the new Democratic governor’s power.  Clark’s thumping of Lumbard in the Mayor’s race made her the first candidate in at least 30 years to oust an incumbent in Tustin.  So Lumbard is now seeking to usurp Clark’s power as Mayor appointing city councilmembers to regional boards and commissions as a lame duck.

Under California law, a directly-elected Mayor makes all of these appointments.  The positions are appointed annually and have always been made after the council reorganizes (with the appointment of a new Mayor Pro Tem, and after the election results have been certified in election years.

But before Clark can even be sworn in, Lumbard wants one more opportunity to shape Tustin government.  The November 17 City Council agenda includes a sweeping package of mayoral appointments to city and regional committees, changes to City Council ad hoc committees, elimination of a pension funding study committee, and establishment of a permanent Veterans Advisory Committee.

The accompanying appointment list identifies the people Lumbard wants serving on these bodies. And under the proposed terms, some appointments could remain in place until an appointee is replaced, resigns, or becomes otherwise ineligible.  That’s quite a parting gift from a mayor who just lost his job.

Lumbard, in his last meeting as Mayor, is trying to have conservative Ray Schnell replace him on the OCFA Board and place John Nielsen—the retrograde councilmember from the Jerry Amante era—to the OC Sanitation District.  These regional positions hold substantial power.  OC Sanitation has a $634 million budget, six times the size of the City of Tustin.  Not only is OCFA’s budget more than $1 Billion, but the OC firefighters union is one of the biggest spenders in local campaigns.  It spent more than $70,000 trying to prop up Lumbard’s failed campaign (part of a record $160,000 in outside IEs spent against Clark, including racist dog whistle mailers).  In fact, Lumbard’s proposal would leave Clark off of any regional board, despite that Clark being the highest vote-getter in Tustin history.

Lumbard ran a dirty campaign, with one of his supporters (the ominously-named “California Homeowner’s Association”) spreading racist dog whistle mailers against Clark, while Lumbard himself claimed to be supported by the Democratic Party, probably because he knew that his own Republican Party was facing an historic election debacle.

These aren’t just appointments. They’re opportunities to shape regional policy—and collect stipends.

Many of Tustin’s regional board appointments must be filled by sitting City Council members. Traditionally, the mayor has consulted with individual council members about their interests, availability, and preferred assignments. Those conversations also allow the mayor to consider how each appointment supports the administration’s priorities and vision for the city.

That process matters. The mayor is not simply filling vacancies. The mayor is helping determine who represents Tustin on regional bodies responsible for transportation, fire protection, sanitation, water, and other critical public services.

Under Lumbard’s proposed roster, Republican council members John Nielsen and Ray Schnell would receive multiple assignments to influential regional boards, including positions that provide per-meeting stipends.

Nielsen is proposed for the Orange County Sanitation District, Newport Bay Watershed Executive Committee, Senior Fund Board, Water Advisory Committee, and the new Veterans Advisory Committee, among other assignments.

Schnell is proposed for the Orange County Fire Authority, Foothill/Eastern Transportation Corridor Agencies, Orange County Sanitation District, Orange County Library Advisory Board, and Santa Ana River Flood Protection Agency.

Ryan Gallagher is proposed for the Legacy Ad Hoc, PCE Ad Hoc, and Newport Bay Watershed Executive Committee.

Meanwhile, Councilmember Lee Fink, the Council’s Democrat, is proposed for just two regional assignments: the Orange County Library Advisory Board and Santa Ana River Flood Protection Agency. Neither assignment provides a meeting stipend, according to information provided about the proposed appointments.

The contrast raises a legitimate question: Why are the paid and highly coveted regional appointments being concentrated among Republican council members while the Council’s Democrat receives two unpaid assignments?

The issue is not whether these council members are qualified to serve. It is whether the distribution of opportunities is equitable, transparent, and consistent with the interests of Tustin residents. Regional board service can provide council members with influence over major policy decisions, relationships with regional leaders, and additional compensation through meeting stipends. Those opportunities should not be treated as political rewards.  And they certainly should not be allocated in a way that excludes the incoming mayor from participating in the process.

The OCFA appointment is especially troubling

Perhaps the most consequential appointment on the November 17 agenda is the Orange County Fire Authority Board of Directors.  The OCFA oversees fire protection and emergency response services across much of Orange County, including Tustin. Its board makes decisions affecting public safety, emergency preparedness, budgets, and regional fire services. It is one of the most influential regional assignments available to a Tustin council member.

Lumbard proposes appointing Ray Schnell to that seat before Clark takes office.  But Clark has expressed a personal interest in serving on the OCFA Board as mayor.

By making this appointment before the new mayor is sworn in, Lumbard is not simply denying Clark the opportunity to recommend an appointee. He is potentially denying her the opportunity to serve on the board herself.

That is a significant distinction.

Under the city’s traditional process, an incoming mayor would have an opportunity to discuss regional assignments with council members, consider the city’s priorities, and determine where the mayor’s own participation could be most beneficial.  Instead, Lumbard is asking the Council to approve the roster before Clark has the opportunity to participate in those conversations.  Why should the outgoing mayor decide who occupies one of the city’s most important regional seats when the voters have already chosen his successor?  And what is the urgency that prevents the Council from waiting until the new mayor takes office?

The Veterans Committee gets a political makeover

Another revealing proposal involves the creation of a new standing Veterans Advisory Committee.  The proposed membership includes Councilmembers John Nielsen and Ray Schnell, American Legion representative Mike Lopez, Veterans Outpost representative Derick Burton, and three at-large members: Johnny Johnson, Angie Kardashian, and Pat Remolacio.

The committee would advise the Council on veterans’ issues, preserve Tustin’s military history, support veterans and their families, and assist with fundraising for a veterans museum. Those are worthwhile goals. Tustin’s veterans deserve recognition, meaningful representation, and a voice in decisions affecting their community.  But why is Lumbard establishing the committee and selecting its inaugural membership now?

The proposed committee is intended to be a permanent advisory body, meeting quarterly and receiving ongoing city staff support. Its formation will shape how Tustin approaches veterans’ issues for years to come.  There is no apparent reason the incoming mayor could not participate in shaping the committee’s mission, membership, and priorities.  If the goal is genuinely to serve veterans, postponing these appointments until the new mayor takes office should not undermine that objective.  Instead, it would demonstrate a commitment to continuity, collaboration, and respect for the incoming administration.

What happened to pension oversight?

Lumbard also proposes eliminating the UAL and Pension Funding Study Ad Hoc Committee, currently assigned to Nielsen and Schnell.  The committee was created to examine Tustin’s unfunded accrued liabilities, pension obligations, and potential funding strategies.  The staff report states that the committee has served its function.  But what did it accomplish?  Where are its findings? What recommendations were made? Have the city’s long-term pension obligations been adequately addressed?  Pension liabilities do not disappear when a mayor leaves office. Taxpayers remain responsible for those obligations long after the November 17 meeting.  Before discontinuing the committee, the Council should provide a public accounting of its work and explain how pension oversight will continue.

The law may allow it. But should the Council approve it?

Lumbard’s staff report cites California Government Code Section 40605, which generally authorizes an elected mayor in a general-law city to make appointments to boards, commissions, and committees, subject to City Council approval.  That provides a legal basis for the appointment process. It does not automatically mean making appointments during a lame-duck period violates state law.  Imagine if a Democratic mayor had done this to an incoming Republican Mayor-elect?

But legality is not the only question.  For years, the appointment process has involved consultation between the mayor and council members about their interests and how their regional service aligns with the city’s leadership priorities.  That opportunity is now being taken away from the incoming mayor.  Clark has already raised questions with the city attorney about the timing of the appointments, the authority to make them, and whether the incoming mayor and Council can revisit the decisions.  Those are important questions, and the public deserves clear answers.

The Council should explain why these appointments must be approved before the new mayor is sworn in, whether they can be reconsidered afterward, and what practical limitations may apply to replacing representatives once they begin serving.  The Council should also disclose which assignments provide stipends, how much they pay, and why certain council members are receiving multiple compensated positions while others are not.

Transparency should not be controversial.

Tustin deserves a transition, not a last-minute power grab

Lumbard had his opportunity to govern. The voters decided they wanted someone else.  Instead of facilitating a smooth transition, his November 17 agenda raises serious questions about whether he is attempting to preserve political influence by filling regional seats and establishing a new advisory body before Clark takes office.  This is about more than political personalities. It is about respecting the authority of the mayor’s office, longstanding practices of consultation, and the public’s expectation that a newly elected mayor will have a meaningful role in shaping the city’s representation.

The mayor’s appointment authority is one of the office’s important leadership responsibilities. While appointments require Council approval, the opportunity to recommend representatives and participate in regional governance is central to the position.  By acting now, the outgoing mayor could effectively prevent his successor from exercising that responsibility at the beginning of her administration.  And in the case of the OCFA Board, he could prevent Clark from serving in a position she has specifically expressed interest in holding.  Imagine if Clark attempted the same maneuver on her way out of office, filling coveted regional positions with political allies just before a Republican successor was sworn in.

Would the same council members defend that decision as routine business?

The Council should seriously consider postponing nonessential appointments until the new mayor takes office, provide a transparent explanation of the distribution of compensated regional assignments, and allow the incoming administration to participate in the process.  Clark won the election. She should have a meaningful opportunity to recommend appointments, consider her own regional service, and work with the Council to determine how Tustin is represented.  Lumbard may still be mayor for a few more weeks.

But the voters have already decided who should lead Tustin next. The outgoing mayor should not be allowed to use his final days in office to make that decision less meaningful.

It’s time to let the next administration begin.  Tustin residents ought to attend the Tustin City Council meeting on Tuesday night to urge the Council to reject this power grab and remind these outgoing crowd voters will remember this in thenext election in 2028.

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *